Creamsicle Jello Shots

Delicious dreamy Creamsicle Jello shots will be a huge hit at your next party! Perfect for summer pool parties, birthdays, and more!

This post may contain affiliate links. I will receive a small commission from these sales at no additional cost to you!

These creamy Jello shots make such a fun party treat! They’ll be a huge hit at your next party or Summer get-together!

These Orange Creamsicle Jello Shots make the perfect party shot! Sweet and refreshing, with the classic combination of vanilla and a creamy, orange flavor. This Jello shot recipe will get ANY party started!

They’re the perfect recipe for 4th of July celebrations, a Halloween party, or any event that brings a large crowd. They pair great with these easy-to-make Summer appetizers, too.

Set aside just a little bit of time and let’s begin whipping up the perfect party treat!

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Toggle

Orange Creamsicle Jello Shot

This easy recipe takes just minutes to make and will be a party favorite in no time!

Supplies Needed for Orange Creamsicle Jello Shots Recipe:

• Plain Vanilla Vodka
• Hot Water
• Orange Jello
• Orange Juice
• Sweetened Condensed Milk
• Whipped Cream (Optional)
• Orange Slices (Optional)

NOTE: Navel orange slices or wedges of Mandarin Oranges would make a great garnish for these creamy Jello shots!

How to Make Creamsicle Orange Jello Shots :

Take these delicious homemade Jello shots to Summer parties or anywhere! They’re super easy to make and a total crowd pleaser.

Start by preparing your Jello, add boiled water and a packet of orange Jello into a large mixing bowl. Do not use cold water, the water must be hot or just boiling for this step.

Stir the orange gelatin in a mixing bowl until it’s fully dissolved.

Let your mixture sit and cool to room temperature. Once cooled, stir the standard vanilla vodka into your orange Jello mixture.

Next, stir in the orange juice.

Using a measuring cup, add in the sweetened condensed milk.

Now, stir together all ingredients until fully combined.

Pour the Jello mixture into plastic shot cups or 2 oz condiment cups. Line them up on a tray or baking sheet prior to pouring for an easier time transferring them into the fridge.

Refrigerate them in plastic cups for 2 hours or until Jello is fully set.

Garnish with a little whipped cream, a small orange wedge, or an orange peel. Serve and enjoy!

Frequently Asked Questions

Tips For A Mess-Free Cleanup:

• Use disposable condiment cups or disposable shot glasses for a quick cleanup. Line them on a party tray ahead of filling shots so they are easier to move and transport.
• Use a pourable measuring cup or injector for ease in filling up each individual shot.
• These handy Jello Shot syringes can be used to transfer the Jello mixture into plastic containers or can be filled up and chilled in the fridge to serve as is. They are a fun way to cool down during a hot Summer day!

Can I Make These Jello Shots Ahead of Time?

For best results, we recommend making these Jello shots up to 2 days in advance for maximum enjoyment. However, they will last in the fridge for up to 2 weeks!

Can I Make A Substitute for Orange Juice?

If you don’t wish to use Orange juice for this recipe, you can easily substitute it for pineapple juice or lime juice instead! Both flavors will slightly change the creamy orange flavor of this recipe and give a more tangy flavor.

Can I Add Garnish to the Jello Shots for Extra Flavor?

Yes! We recommend orange slices, whipped cream, maraschino cherries or pieces of an orange rind as garnish options for your Orange Creamsicle shot. Just be sure to save the garnish for right before serving if you don’t plan on serving these right away!

Can I Add More Liquor to These Jello Shots?

For best results, you should put 1/2 cup of liquor into your Jello Shots. But, you are able to add as much as 2/3 cup without changing the texture of the Jello Shots. If you add too much alcohol to your Jello shots, it may cause the Jello Shots to not set properly.

Orange Creamsicle Jello Shot: Printable Recipe Card

Creamsicle Jello Shots

These creamy Jello shots make such a fun party treat! They’ll be a huge hit at your next party or Summer get together!

Print Pin SaveSaved! Rate

Course: Appetizer, Drinks, Snack

Prep Time: 10 minutes minutes

Chill Time: 2 hours hours

Total Time: 2 hours hours 10 minutes minutes

Yields: 24

What You’ll Need:

• 4 Oz Vanilla Vodka
• 4 Oz Hot Water
• 3 Oz Orange Jello
• 1/2 Cup Orange Juice
• 1/2 Cup Sweetened Condensed Milk
• Whipped Cream Optional
• Orange Slices Optional

Instructions:

• Start by preparing your Jello, add boiled water and a packet of orange Jello into a large mixing bowl. Do not use cold water, the water must be hot or just boiling for this step.
  4 Oz Hot Water, 3 Oz Orange Jello
• Stir the orange gelatin in a mixing bowl until it’s fully dissolved.
• Let your mixture sit to cool to room temperature. Once cooled, stir the standard vanilla vodka into your orange Jello mixture.
  4 Oz Vanilla Vodka
• Next, stir in the orange juice.
  1/2 Cup Orange Juice
• Using a measuring cup, add in the sweetened condensed milk.
  1/2 Cup Sweetened Condensed Milk
• Now, stir all ingredients until fully combined.
• Pour the Jello mixture into plastic shot cups or 2 oz condiment cups. Line them up on a tray or baking sheet prior to pouring for an easier time transferring them into the fridge.

  Refrigerate them in plastic cups for 2 hours or until Jello is fully set.
• Garnish with a little whipped cream, a small orange wedge, or an orange peel. Serve and enjoy!
  Whipped Cream, Orange Slices

Did You Make This?Mention @HeidiKundin or tag #hihmakersclub on Instagram to show off your awesome work! ♥

ALL of your friends and family will enjoy a fun night of barbecuing and throwing back a few of these delicious, mouth-watering Jello shots!

If you’re looking for even more fun Jello shot recipes, be sure to check out this list of 25+ of the best Jello shot recipes around. Don’t forget to pin this recipe for later & tell us how your Jello shots turn out in the comments section below!